Photocopies of a series of articles and letters to "The Pilot" from October 1903 to February 1904 set off by an article entitled, "M. Loisy's New Book" (Oct. 24, 1903). A note sheet included with the packet includes a list of possible identities for the pseudonyms used and a note that reads, "None of these 1903 reviews or letters is (necessarily) by GT. But this packet traces a whole long controversy in The Pilot, and includes 2 articles/letters by T."